A Quasi Experimental Study to Assess the
Effectiveness of Structured Teaching Programme on
Knowledge and Attitude Regarding Prevention of Oral Cancer among the Students
of Higher Secondary in Selected Schools of Jalandhar,
Punjab 2015
Kamalpreer
Kaur1*, Kumari Lalita2, Begum Nilavansa S.3
1Student, Department of Child Health Nursing, Professor
cum Principal
2Department of Maternal and Child Health Nursing, Assistant
professor
3Department of Community Health Nursing, S.G.L Nursing College Semi Jalandhar, Punjab.
*Corresponding Author’s Email: kamal_9minhas@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT:
Oral cancer or mouth cancer
is one of the leading cancers in the world. It is a cancer that occurs in any
part of the mouth; on the tongue's surface, in the lips, inside the cheeks, in
the gums, in the roof and floor of the mouth, in the tonsils, and also in the
salivary glands. Most persons have no detectable symptoms during the early stages
of oral cancer. When signs and symptoms do appear, they typically include:
Patches on the lining of the mouth or tongue, usually red or red and white in colour, mouth ulcers that do not go away, a sore that does
not heal, pain when swallowing, jaw pain, jaw stiffness etc.
The main aim of the study is
to enhance the knowledge and attitude regarding prevention of oral cancer among
the students of higher secondary by providing structured teaching programme. For this study, a quasi experimental research
design was used. The study was conducted on 160 samples of students. Every
sample was selected by stratified random sampling technique. As age, gender and
class was kept as strata. The study was conducted in PAP Government Senior
Secondary school, Victor Model school, Government Senior Secondary school Ladhewali and Saint Soldier Public school. Data was
collected by socio-demographic variables, self structured knowledge and
attitude questionnaire.
Collected data was analyzed
by descriptive and inferential statistics. Tables and Bar diagrams were used to
depict the findings. The pre test mean knowledge score was 12.21 and the pre
test mean attitude score was 33.12 where as the post test mean knowledge score
was 20.04 and post test attitude score was 34.02.
The difference between pre
test and post test mean knowledge score regarding prevention of oral cancer was
statistically significant. The tcal 24.072
< ttable 1.97 at p <0.05. The difference between pre test and post test
attitude score regarding prevention of oral cancer was statistically
significant. The tcal 05.012
< ttable 1.97 at p<0.05. So, it
indicates that structured teaching programme had
significant impact on knowledge and attitude of students regarding prevention
of oral cancer.
KEYWORDS: Knowledge, Attitude,
Students of higher secondary.
INTRODUCTION:
“Health
is wealth and let our school children enjoy good health with good education,
better health with better education and best health with best education”
Oral cancer or mouth
cancer is one of the leading cancers in the world. It is a cancer that
occurs in any part of the mouth; on the tongue's surface, in the lips, inside
the cheeks, in the gums, in the roof and floor of the mouth, in the tonsils,
and also in the salivary glands. Most persons have no detectable symptoms
during the early stages of oral cancer. When signs and symptoms do appear, they
typically include: Patches on the lining of the mouth or tongue, usually
red or red and white in colour, mouth ulcers that do
not go away, a sore that does not heal, pain when swallowing, jaw pain, jaw
stiffness etc.
As
per World Health Organization report 2013 oral cancer accounts for
approximately 3, 00, 00000 deaths annually worldwide including 1, 30,000 cases
of oral cancer are being found only in India.2 There is evidence
that this cancer is more common in the developing countries in contrast to the
developed ones, with the highest oral cavity cancer rates being found in
Malaysia, South-Central Asia, and Central and Eastern Europe and the lowest in
Africa, Central America, and Eastern Asia for both males and females.
India
is the second largest producer of tobacco and most of the tobacco produced is
consumed within the country only, with approximately 274.9 million tobacco
users according to recent data (Global Adult Tobacco Survey-GATS, 2010). As per
this report more than one-third (35%) of adults in India use tobacco in some
form or the other, 163.7 million are users of only smokeless tobacco, 68.9
million do smoking, and 42.3 million users are of both smoking and smokeless
tobacco.
Oral cancer is a serious
public health problem with over 3, 00, 00000 new cases are reported annually
worldwide, two- third of which occurs in developing countries. The overall
mortality rate for intra- oral cancer remains high at approximately 50 % even with
modern medical services, probably due to the advanced stage of the disease.
This outlines recent advances in the understanding of the roles and
interactions of major risk factors for oral- cancer worldwide, notably tobacco,
alcohol and betel quid and the genetic polymorphisms determining their
metabolism that may predispose patients to oral carcinoma.
A WHO international Agency
conducted a study in 2008 for research on cancer concluded that smokeless
tobacco users have an 80% higher risk of developing oral cancer and 60% higher
risk of developing pancreatic and oesophageal cancer.
Chewing tobacco has been linked to dental caries. A study by the “National
Institute of Health” and the “Centres for Disease
Control and Prevention” found chewing tobacco users were four times more likely
than non-users to have decayed dental root surfaces.
Biswas AK, Sarkar J. J Pak Association 2010 conducted study on tobacco use among
urban school boys of Paschim Midnapore,
west Bengal India out of 454
students, 201(44.3%) were ever users of tobacco whereas 135(29.7%) were current
users. Majority of the current users utilized both form of tobacco. Initiation
of tobacco before 10 years were more in smokeless (11.4%) form than smoking (4.5%),
but smokers showed steep rise (49.3%) at 14-15 years. Proportion of current
users significantly (p < 0.001) increased along with increase in pocket
money. Compared to non-users current users had more exposure to tobacco in the
family and friends. Both current users and nonusers showed positive attitude
towards tobacco use. Though knowledge of harmful effects of tobacco was well
perceived but significantly more (p < 0.005) non-users had shown interest to
prohibit smoking in public places. More non-users (75%) than ever users
(26.4%) had shown favourable opinion regarding future
tobacco use.
A WHO international Agency conducted a study in 2008 for research on
cancer concluded that smokeless tobacco users have an 80% higher risk of
developing oral cancer and 60% higher risk of developing pancreatic and oesophageal cancer. Chewing tobacco has been linked to
dental caries. A study by the “National Institute of Health” and the “Centres for Disease Control and Prevention” found chewing
tobacco users were four times more likely than non-users to have decayed dental
root surfaces.
Ali NS., Khuwaja
AK., Ali T., Hameed R, (2009)
conducted study on smokeless tobacco use among children who visited
family practice clinics in Karachi, Pakistan.
The objective of study was to estimate proportion of use and the
knowledge about smokeless tobacco in relation to cancer. This study concludes that over half of the
children were using smokeless tobacco and had poor knowledge about its hazards
and the study suggests that there was a need for socially and culturally acceptable
educational and behavioural interventions for control
of smokeless tobacco usage.
Institute of cytology and
preventive oncology, 2005 conducted on knowledge, attitude and practice of
tobacco use among school students in Noida UP. Two
schools covering 299 students were included in this study. The frequency of
ever smoking was 9.0% and that of chewing was 6.0%. The Current smokers and
chewers were 3.3% and 4.7% respectively. Out of 299 students the numbers of
girls included in the sample were 55. The frequency of current or ever smoking
and chewing among girls was 3.6% and 1.8% respectively.
OBJECTIVES:
1. To assess
the knowledge regarding Prevention of Oral Cancer among the students of higher
secondary before structured teaching programme.
2. To assess
the attitude regarding Prevention of Oral Cancer among the students of higher
secondary before structured teaching programme.
3. To assess
the knowledge regarding Prevention of Oral Cancer among the students of higher
secondary after structured teaching programme.
4. To assess
the attitude regarding Prevention of Oral Cancer among the students of higher
secondary after structured teaching programme.
5. To assess
the effect of structured teaching programme on
knowledge regarding Prevention of Oral Cancer among students of higher
secondary.
6. To assess
the effect of structured teaching programme on
attitude regarding Prevention of Oral Cancer among students of higher
secondary
7. To
determine the association between the knowledge regarding Prevention of Oral
Cancer among the students of higher secondary with selected socio-demographic
variables.
8. To
determine the association between the attitude regarding Prevention of Oral
Cancer among the students of higher secondary with selected socio-demographic
variables.
HYPOTHESIS:
H1: The post test mean knowledge and attitude score
regarding prevention of oral cancer is significantly higher than post test mean knowledge and attitude score (p <0.05
level of significance).
H0: The post test mean knowledge and attitude score
regarding prevention of oral cancer is not significantly higher than post test
mean knowledge and attitude score.
MATERIALS AND METHODS:
Research approach-Quantitative research approach was used for the study.
Research design-The term research design
refers to the plan or organization of a scientific investigation.
Research setting
The
study was conducted in the selected Schools of Jalandhar
in the month of April, 2015 on higher secondary school students from PAP
Government senior secondary school, Victor Model School, Government senior
secondary school Ladhewali and Saint Soldier School, Jalandhar, Punjab.
Total population:
It consists of students of
higher secondary in selected schools of Jalandhar
Punjab.
Target population:
The
target population include the students of higher secondary schools PAP
Government school, Victor Model school, Government senior secondary school Ladhewali, Saint Soldier School Jalandhar,
Punjab.
Sample size and sampling
technique:
Total 160 students of higher Secondary schools were
selected. Stratified random sampling technique was employed collect sample.
age, gender and class were set as strata.
Criteria for sample selection:
Inclusion criteria
1.
The Students
who were willing to participate in the study.
2. The Students from
selected schools of Jalandhar.
Exclusion criteria:
1. Students who were
above 18years of age.
Research variables:
Independent
variable:
The independent variable is Structured Teaching Programme on prevention of oral cancer among students of
higher secondary schools.
Dependent
variable:
The Dependent variable is knowledge and attitude
regarding prevention of oral cancer.
Socio
– demographic variables of the study:
The socio demographic variable of the study
were Age (in years), Gender, Class, Type of school, Type of family, Residence,
Education of mother, Education of father, Father’s occupation, Mother’s
occupation and Family income (in rupees).
Selection
and development of tool:
As study is on effect of structured teaching programme on knowledge and attitude regarding prevention of
oral cancer among students of higher secondary in selected schools of Jalandhar, Punjab, therefore a tool is prepared in the form
of self structured knowledge and attitude questionnaire to assess the knowledge
and attitude score of the selected sample. Preliminary drafting of tool is
prepared after extensive review of literature and consulting with subject
experts.
The tool was divided into four parts:
Part
1- Socio-demographic variables:
It consisted of socio- demographic variables. age
(in years), gender, class, type of school, type of family, residence, education
of mother, education of father, father’s occupation, mother’s occupation and
family income (in rupees).
Part
2: It consisted of structured teaching programme regarding prevention of oral cancer.
Part
3: A Self
Structured Knowledge and attitude Questionnaire consisted of 24 multiple choice
questions regarding prevention of oral cancer. Each correct answer was awarded
1 mark and incorrect answer was awarded 0 marks.
|
Level of
Knowledge |
Score |
% |
|
Excellent |
20 – 24 |
83.33-100 |
|
Good |
14 - 19 |
58.33-79.17 |
|
Average |
08 - 13 |
33.33 - 54.17 |
Maximum score=
24
Minimum score
= 00
Part
4: It consisted of 5 point rated Attitude scale
regarding the prevention of oral Cancer which consist of 10 questions.
|
Level of
attitude |
Score |
% |
|
Strongly positive |
41-50 |
85.00-100 |
|
Positive |
31-40 |
63.33-83.33 |
|
Neutral |
21-30 |
41.67- 61.67 |
|
Negative |
Nov-20 |
21.67- 40.00 |
|
Strongly Negative |
00-10 |
00.00-20.00 |
Maximum Score = 50
Minimum Score = 00
Validity
of tool and content:
The content validity of the
tool was determined by the expert’s opinion on the relevance of items. These
experts were from the specialty of Community Health Nursing, Child Health
Nursing. The suggestions were incorporated after consultation with the research
supervisor. The self structured knowledge and attitude questionnaire is used
which comprise of 24 questions in knowledge and 10 questions in attitude scale
for assessment of knowledge and
attitude regarding prevention of oral
cancer among students of higher secondary schools. The self structured
knowledge and attitude questioner was translated into Punjabi by language
experts for the purpose of data collection.
Pilot study:
The pilot study was
conducted in the month of Feburary, 2015, to
determine the reliability of the tool and feasibility of the study. The study
was conducted in Mata Ganga Public school Rama Mandi Jalandhar Cantt. Pilot Study was conducted on 16 students of higher
secondary, to identify the reliability of the tool and feasibility of the
study. Pilot study was started on 22-02-15 and completed on 1-03-15.Written
informed consent was taken from each parents and students and prior
instructions were given to the students. Pre test knowledge and attitude was
assessed by self structured knowledge and attitude questioner. Structured
Teaching Programme was given for 45 minutes only to
group. After seven days, post test knowledge and attitude of group was assessed
with the help of same self structured knowledge and attitude questionnaire.
Reliability of tool:
It is the degree of
consistency or accuracy with which an instrument measures the attribute it is
designed to measure. Reliability was obtained by test retest method and was
calculated by Karl’s Pearson co-efficient of co-relation formula. The
reliability of tool was 0.75, which indicated the tool was reliable.
Data collection procedure:
The data collection
procedure of the study was carried out in the month of April 2015 from PAP
School, Victor Model School, Government School, Saint Soldier Divine Public
schools of Jalandhar, Punjab. Before collecting the
data, investigator obtained permission from selected schools of jalandhar. Data was collected from students of higher secondary
and the sample size was 160. The investigator had taken written informed
consent from the students and their parents for participation in the study.
Participants were assured that their responses would be kept confidential and
used only for research purpose. Pre test knowledge of group was assessed by
self structured knowledge and attitude questionnaire. A structured teaching programme regarding prevention of oral cancer was given to
the group. Post test knowledge of group was assessed after seven days.
Ethical considerations:
1. Ethical
permission was taken from the Principal of S.G.L nursing college Semi, Jalandhar, Punjab.
2. Written
permission was obtained from the research ethical clearance committee of S.G.L
Nursing College Semi, Jalandhar, Punjab.
3. Written
permission was obtained from Principals of selected schools of Jalandhar, Punjab.
4. Informed
written consent was obtained from the samples and parents.
5.
Confidentiality and anonymity of study subjects was maintained throughout the
study.
Plan of data analysis:
Data analysis and
interpretation of data was done according to the objectives of the study.
Analysis was done by using descriptive and inferential statistic. Descriptive
statistic used was Frequency, Percentages, Mean and S.D. Inferential statistics
used were chi square test and ANOVA test.
MAJOR
FINDINGS:
·
According
to age (in years), majority of students were in age group of 97(60.6%)
17-18years, followed by 63(39.4%) were in 15-16years.
·
In
gender, majority were females 90(56.2%) whereas males were70 (43.8%).
·
As per
class 75(46.9%) were 10+1 and 85(53.1%) were 10+2 qualified.
·
According
to type of school, majority of students were from private school 97(60.6%)
where as 63(39.4%) were from government school.
·
In
accordance with residence, majority of students 149(93.1) were from urban
areas, 11(6.9%) were from rural area.
·
As per
type of family majority of students belongs to nuclear family 93(58.1%) and
67(41.9%) were from joint family.
·
According
to educational status of mother, majority of mothers were having secondary
education 85(53.1%), followed by 40(25%) graduation or above, 23(14.4%) were
primary and only 12(7.5%) were illiterate.
·
According
to educational status of father, majority of fathers were having secondary
education 70(43.8%), followed by 59(36.8%) were graduated or above, 20(12.5%)
were primary and only 11(6.9%) were illiterate.
·
As per
fathers occupation, majority of fathers were skilled 130(81.2%), 30(18.8%) were
unskilled.
·
As per
mother’s occupation, mother’s had same results in skilled and unskilled
80(50.0%).
·
In
accordance with family income, majority of students had monthly family income
71(44.3%) of Rs 10,000rs, 51(33.9%) had in between Rs 10,000-20,000, and
38(23.8%) were having above Rs20, 000.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT:
My study is purely dedicated to my guruji
and beloved parents.
REFERENCES:
1.
What is
oral cancer, causes of oral cancer, sign and symptom of oral cancer? Available
from: http://www.medicalnewstoday. com/articles/165331.php.
2.
World
health organization report on the global tobacco epidemic 2009. Available from:https://www.google.co.in.search
?q=who+report+on+global+tobacco+epidemic.
3.
Farley
J, et al(2010). Estimates of worldwide burden of cancer in 2008: GLOBOCAN 2008.
Int J Cancer, 12 2893-917.
4.
Narayan Raj, Asthana Samita,
Satyanarayana L. Assessment of prevalence of tobacco
use and impact of health education among school students.. Annual report
2003-2005.
5.
Narayan Raj, Asthana Samita,
Satyanarayana L. Assessment of prevalence of tobacco
use and impact of health education among school students.. Annual report
2003-2005.
6.
C Das Bhudev, C. Bharti Alok, Hedai Suresh, Institute of
cytology and Preventive oncology, Annual report 2003- 2005.
7.
C Das Bhudev, C. Bharti Alok, Hedai Suresh, Institute of
cytology and Preventive oncology, Annual report 2003- 2005.
8.
C Das Bhudev, C. Bharti Alok, Hedai Suresh, Institute of
cytology and Preventive oncology, Annual report 2003- 2005.
9.
Data of
Punjab regarding the cases of oral cancer.http://www.timesofindia.indiatimes.com.
10.
Jemal A, Brey F, Center M, et al (2011).Global
Cancer Statistics. CA: Cancer J Clin/article/61;
69-90.
Received on 22.09.2015 Modified on 19.10.2015
Accepted on 30.10.2015 © A&V Publications all right reserved
Int. J. Adv. Nur. Management 4(1): Jan. - Mar. 2016; Page 11-15
DOI: 10.5958/2454-2652.2016.00003.2